Choosing a dildo should feel exciting, not overwhelming. With so many shapes, sizes, materials and styles available, the easiest place to start is by thinking about what you want the toy to do: feel realistic, target a specific spot, offer fullness, work hands-free, or simply help you explore at your own pace.
This guide breaks down the main things to consider before buying, so you can choose something that feels comfortable, body-safe and right for your experience level.
Start with the sensation you want
Before choosing a size or style, think about the feeling you’re looking for.
If you want something simple and approachable, a smooth silicone dildo is usually a good starting point. It gives you control, is easy to clean and doesn’t feel too visually intense.
If you want a lifelike look and feel, a realistic dildo may be a better fit. These often have more anatomical detail, different skin-tone options and a firmer or dual-density feel.
If you want targeted internal stimulation, look for a curved dildo designed for G-spot or P-spot play. The curve helps apply pressure to specific areas rather than simply adding fullness.
If you want hands-free play, choose a suction cup base or harness-compatible design. These give you more freedom with positions and are useful for solo or partnered play.
Choose a size that suits your experience level
Bigger is not automatically better. The best size is the one you can use comfortably and confidently.
For beginners, a slimmer or medium-sized dildo is usually the safest choice. Look for a tapered tip, a smooth shape and a size that doesn’t feel intimidating.
If you already know you enjoy fuller toys, you may prefer a thicker or longer option. Just remember that comfort matters more than ego, and there’s no prize for choosing something too large too soon.
A good rule: if you’re unsure, start smaller than you think and size up later.
Understand the different materials
Material matters because it affects feel, firmness, cleaning and body safety.
Silicone is one of the most popular choices because it is body-safe, non-porous, easy to clean and available in soft or firm finishes. Use water-based lubricant with silicone toys unless the manufacturer says otherwise.
Glass is firm, smooth and great for temperature play. It can feel intense because it doesn’t flex, so it suits people who like precise pressure.
ABS plastic is firm, smooth and often used in vibrating or structured toys. It’s easy to clean and usually budget-friendly.
Real-feel or soft-touch materials can feel more lifelike, but they may require extra care. Check whether the toy is non-porous and always follow the cleaning instructions.
Think about shape, not just size
Shape changes the experience as much as size does.
A straight dildo is simple, versatile and easy to control.
A curved dildo is better for targeted stimulation, especially if you want pressure toward the front wall of the body.
A textured dildo adds ridges, bumps or veins for more sensation, which can feel great for some people and too intense for others.
A double-ended dildo is designed for shared play or flexible positioning, but it usually suits people with more experience.
A suction cup dildo gives you hands-free options and can attach to smooth surfaces like tiles or glass.
Don’t forget lubricant
Lubricant makes a huge difference to comfort. Even if a toy looks smooth, lube helps reduce friction and makes play feel easier and more enjoyable.
For most dildos, a good water-based lubricant is the safest all-round choice because it works with most materials, including silicone.
If you’re using the toy anally, choose a lubricant designed for anal play and make sure the toy has a flared base.
Cleaning and storage matter
Clean your toy before and after use with warm water and a suitable toy cleaner, then let it dry fully before storing it.
Store toys separately where possible, especially if they are made from softer materials. A storage pouch helps keep dust away and protects the surface.
If a toy changes texture, smell or appearance, it may be time to replace it.
Quick guide: which dildo should you choose?
Beginner-friendly: smooth silicone, medium or slim size, tapered tip.
Realistic feel: lifelike or dual-density dildo with anatomical detail.
G-spot or P-spot focus: curved design with a firm enough shaft for pressure.
Hands-free play: suction cup base or harness-compatible toy.
Fuller sensation: thicker dildo, but only if you already know you enjoy size.
Shared play: double-ended or harness-compatible options.
Final thought
The right dildo is not the biggest or most expensive one. It’s the one that suits your body, your comfort level and the kind of pleasure you’re curious about.
If you’re unsure where to start, choose body-safe materials, a manageable size and plenty of lubricant. You can always explore more adventurous shapes later.
Explore the full Dildos & Dongs collection online, or visit Naughty But Nice in Cannon Hill, Capalaba or Margate for discreet, friendly advice.